Skip to content 
When Safety Measures Fail: Understanding Your Rights
A negligent security attorney is a legal professional who helps victims injured due to inadequate security measures on someone else’s property. If you’ve been harmed because a property owner failed to provide reasonable security, you may have a valid claim.
Quick Guide to Negligent Security Claims:
– Definition: Legal claims arising when property owners fail to provide adequate security measures, resulting in foreseeable crimes and injuries
– When to Call: After being assaulted, robbed, or otherwise harmed on someone else’s property
– Typical Cases: Assaults in poorly lit parking lots, attacks in apartments with broken locks, hotel room invasions due to inadequate security
– Compensation: Medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages
– Time Limits: Varies by state (1-6 years), with shorter deadlines for government properties
Every 35 minutes, someone in the United States becomes a victim of murder. Countless others suffer assaults, robberies, and sexual attacks that could have been prevented with proper security measures. When these tragic events occur, victims often feel helpless – unaware that property owners can be held legally responsible.
Negligent security falls under premises liability law, which holds property owners accountable for maintaining reasonably safe conditions. Unlike other personal injury cases, these claims specifically address situations where inadequate security measures contributed to a criminal attack.
The stakes in these cases can be high. Some negligent security lawsuits have resulted in multi-million dollar settlements, including a record $102.7 million verdict.
If you or a loved one has been harmed because someone failed to provide adequate security, understanding your legal options is crucial. Time limits for filing claims vary significantly between states, and evidence must be preserved quickly.
What Is Negligent Security & Why It Matters
When you visit a hotel, shop at a mall, or park your car in a garage, you expect to be safe. But what happens when that safety is compromised because someone didn’t take proper precautions to protect you? That’s where negligent security comes into play.
Negligent security occurs when property owners fail to provide reasonable protection against foreseeable criminal acts. It’s about holding property owners accountable when they knew (or should have known) about potential dangers but didn’t take steps to address them.
The foundation of these cases is the “duty of care” that property owners owe to visitors. This legal responsibility means taking reasonable measures to keep people safe from harm that could be anticipated. When owners ignore this duty and someone gets hurt, they can be held responsible—even though they didn’t commit the crime themselves.
The physical toll of these incidents can be devastating. CDC research shows that assault injuries frequently affect the head (30%) and upper trunk (10%) of victims. Most injuries fall into three main categories: contusions/abrasions (40%), lacerations (20%), and fractures (15%). Learn more about these patterns in the CDC’s research on assault injury patterns.
Negligent Security Attorney Basics
A negligent security attorney helps victims steer the complex legal landscape after suffering injuries due to inadequate security. These legal professionals understand how to prove that a property owner’s negligence contributed to your injuries.
Most negligent security attorneys, including our team at The Barzakay Law Firm, work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront, and we only get paid if we secure compensation for you.
These cases are civil actions, separate from any criminal proceedings against the attacker. While criminal courts focus on punishing the perpetrator, your civil claim seeks financial compensation for your injuries and suffering.
Foreseeability and Legal Duty
Foreseeability is the heart of every negligent security case. For a property owner to be legally responsible, the criminal act must have been reasonably predictable based on circumstances such as:
Prior similar crimes in the area make future incidents more foreseeable. If three robberies occurred in a parking garage last year, the owner should anticipate and prevent future ones.
Crime grid analysis examines criminal activity patterns in the surrounding area. Courts often review these geographic analyses to determine whether the owner should have anticipated potential problems.
Reasonable measures vary by property type and location. What’s reasonable for a downtown nightclub differs from what’s expected at a suburban bookstore. Security measures should match the known risks.
The law doesn’t require property owners to prevent all possible crimes—that would be impossible. Instead, it requires them to take reasonable steps based on known risks.
Common Scenarios, Locations & Liable Parties
When security measures fail, the consequences can be devastating. Negligent security cases often stem from everyday situations where property owners simply didn’t take reasonable steps to keep people safe.
The most common security lapses include poor lighting in areas where people walk alone, broken locks that allow unauthorized access, security cameras that don’t work (or aren’t monitored), and undertrained security guards who don’t know how to respond in emergencies. Sometimes, the failure is even more basic – like overgrown bushes that create perfect hiding spots for attackers.
Where do these incidents typically happen? According to Bureau of Justice Statistics data, apartment complexes top the list, followed by hotels and motels where travelers expect safety but don’t always find it. Parking lots and garages are particularly dangerous, especially at night. Nightclubs and bars where alcohol is served create additional risks, while gas stations and convenience stores that stay open late are frequent targets. Other common locations include office buildings, college campuses, hospitals, and ATM locations.
When these tragedies occur, several parties might bear responsibility. The property owner who failed to fix broken security equipment, the property management company that ignored tenant complaints about safety, the security company that didn’t properly train its guards, or the landlord who never installed proper locks despite multiple break-ins. Sometimes business operators who rent space or homeowners’ associations that manage common areas share responsibility too.
Crimes & Incidents That Trigger Claims
The crimes that lead to negligent security claims are often violent and traumatic. Physical assaults where victims are beaten, sometimes with weapons, are all too common. Armed robberies that turn violent, especially in retail settings or parking areas, leave lasting trauma.
Tragically, sexual assaults often occur in places where security should have prevented an attacker from gaining access. Shootings and gun violence in areas without proper security screening or monitoring claim innocent lives. In the most heartbreaking cases, families come to us after a wrongful death that could have been prevented with basic security measures.
Injuries and Damages Victims Suffer
The harm from these incidents goes far beyond the immediate attack. Physical injuries often include head trauma that can cause permanent disability, spinal cord injuries that change lives forever, and broken bones that require surgery and lengthy rehabilitation.
The psychological impact can be just as devastating. Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is extremely common, leaving victims unable to return to normal activities or even the location where the attack occurred. Anxiety and depression can become debilitating, while fear of public places might prevent someone from working or socializing normally.
The financial toll adds another layer of suffering. Medical bills pile up quickly, especially for those without adequate insurance. Lost wages hurt immediately, while diminished earning capacity affects victims for years.
Building a Winning Negligent Security Claim
When you’ve been hurt because a property owner failed to keep you safe, building a strong legal case requires several key elements. Think of these elements as the foundation of your claim:
The property owner had a duty of care to protect you as a visitor. They breached that duty by not providing adequate security measures. This security failure was a direct cause of the incident that harmed you. And finally, you suffered real damages – physical injuries, emotional trauma, or financial losses.
Time is truly of the essence in these cases. Property owners often rush to fix security problems after an incident occurs – installing new lights, repairing broken locks, or adding cameras. While these improvements might prevent future incidents, they can erase crucial evidence of the negligence that led to your injury.
That’s why contacting a negligent security attorney quickly can make all the difference. At The Barzakay Law Firm, we immediately work to preserve vital evidence like police reports, crime scene photos, and maintenance records showing neglected security features.
Be aware that time limits for filing your claim vary dramatically depending on where you live. These “statutes of limitations” range from just one year in Tennessee to six years in places like Minnesota, North Dakota, and Maine. Here in Florida, you typically have four years from the date of the incident to file your claim, though certain circumstances may affect this timeline.
Claims against government entities often have even shorter deadlines, sometimes requiring notice within just 90-180 days. Missing these deadlines can permanently bar you from seeking compensation.
How a Negligent Security Attorney Helps You
When you work with a negligent security attorney from The Barzakay Law Firm, you gain a dedicated advocate who handles all aspects of your case while you focus on recovery.
We start with a thorough investigation, examining crime patterns in the area and security measures that should have been in place. We work with security professionals who can speak to industry standards and how the property fell short.
Evidence preservation is a top priority. We act quickly to document security deficiencies before they’re corrected, taking photos of poor lighting, broken locks, or missing security cameras that contributed to your injuries.
Understanding the full extent of your damages is essential for fair compensation. We consult with medical professionals to fully understand your injuries and future needs, ensuring nothing is overlooked when calculating your claim’s value.
With offices throughout Florida, including Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and Orlando, we provide personalized service to clients across the state. Learn more about our approach at our Security Negligence Lawyer services page.
Key Evidence to Collect Early
If you’ve been injured due to negligent security, the evidence you gather in the immediate aftermath can significantly strengthen your case:
Document the scene with photos and videos that show security problems like broken locks, poor lighting, or missing cameras. If you’re able, file a formal incident report with property management and request a copy for your records.
Gather contact information from witnesses who saw what happened or who might know about ongoing security issues at the property. If there are security cameras, formally request that any surveillance footage be preserved before it’s deleted or recorded over.
Keep detailed records of all your medical treatments, including diagnoses, medications, therapy sessions, and expenses. These documents create a clear link between the incident and your injuries.
Compensation & Record-Setting Verdicts
When you’ve been harmed due to inadequate security, understanding the potential compensation can help you plan for recovery. Victims of negligent security incidents deserve fair compensation for both the visible and invisible costs of their injuries.
Medical bills often pile up quickly after an attack. From emergency room visits to ongoing physical therapy, these expenses can be overwhelming. Beyond immediate healthcare costs, many victims face long-term treatment needs that extend for months or years. Your compensation should cover both current and future medical expenses.
Lost income presents another significant challenge. Whether you missed a few weeks of work or can no longer perform your previous job, this financial impact deserves recognition. Many successful claims include compensation for both immediate lost wages and reduced earning capacity over time.
The physical pain and emotional suffering following an attack often leave the deepest scars. Courts recognize these non-economic damages, which can include:
Pain and suffering from physical injuries, emotional distress that affects your daily life, loss of enjoyment in activities you once loved, and impacts on personal relationships. While no amount of money can erase these experiences, fair compensation acknowledges their profound impact.
In cases where a property owner’s negligence was particularly shocking, punitive damages may be awarded. These additional amounts serve to punish truly reckless behavior and discourage similar negligence by others.
The value of negligent security cases can be substantial. The largest jury verdict in history for such a case reached an astounding $102.7 million. Since 2007, negligent security cases have resulted in cumulative recoveries exceeding $980 million for victims nationwide.
Other notable verdicts include awards of $12 million, $10.1 million, and $8.6 million, with many cases settling in the multi-million dollar range. However, it’s important to understand that each case is unique, with settlement values typically depending on:
- The severity and permanence of your injuries
- How clearly the property owner’s negligence can be established
- Whether the criminal activity was foreseeable
- The property owner’s knowledge of security issues
- How the existing security measures compared to industry standards
Most negligent security claims are covered by the property owner’s general liability insurance. However, in catastrophic injury cases, policy limits sometimes restrict full recovery, making it crucial to have a negligent security attorney who can identify all potential sources of compensation.
Immediate Steps After an Attack
The moments after a security-related attack can feel overwhelming. You’re dealing with physical pain, emotional trauma, and confusion about what to do next. Taking the right steps not only protects your health but also preserves your legal options.
First and foremost, seek medical attention immediately. Even if your injuries seem minor, some conditions like concussions or internal bleeding might not show symptoms right away. A medical professional can properly document your injuries, which becomes crucial evidence for your case.
Contact the police as soon as possible. A detailed police report creates an official record of what happened and may help identify your attacker. Be thorough when describing the incident, including any security issues you noticed like broken locks or poor lighting.
While at the scene (if you’re able), document everything with your smartphone. Take photos of your injuries, the location where the attack occurred, and any obvious security failures. This visual evidence can be powerful in demonstrating negligence.
If the property has security cameras, request that management preserve the footage immediately. Many surveillance systems automatically delete recordings after a certain period, sometimes as short as 24-48 hours. A quick request in writing can prevent crucial evidence from disappearing.
Notify the property owner or manager about what happened. Keep this communication factual and brief – simply report that an incident occurred. Avoid making detailed statements about fault or accepting any settlement offers they might make.
Talk to witnesses while memories are fresh. Get names and contact information from anyone who saw the attack or who might know about ongoing security problems at the property. Their testimony could be invaluable to your case.
Be extremely cautious with insurance adjusters who might contact you. They often call quickly after incidents, hoping to secure statements that could limit their liability. Politely decline to provide detailed statements and refer them to your legal representative.
Consult with a negligent security attorney promptly. At The Barzakay Law Firm, we can help preserve evidence, handle communications with insurance companies, and ensure you don’t miss critical deadlines for filing your claim.
For more detailed information about pursuing compensation as an assault victim, you can read more about negligent security claims in Miami.
Frequently Asked Questions About Negligent Security
What must a victim prove to win?
Winning a negligent security case isn’t about pointing fingers—it’s about establishing clear facts that show responsibility. If you’ve been injured, you’ll need to show four key elements to build a successful claim.
First, you must establish that the property owner had a duty of care toward you. This means they were legally obligated to provide reasonable security based on your relationship—whether you were a tenant, hotel guest, or shopper at their store.
Second, you’ll need to demonstrate a breach of that duty. Maybe the apartment complex ignored broken locks for months, or the hotel didn’t fix hallway lighting despite repeated complaints. These failures to act reasonably can constitute a breach.
Third, you must show causation—that the security failures directly contributed to what happened to you. This often requires showing that proper security measures would likely have prevented the incident altogether.
Finally, you need to document your damages—the actual injuries and losses you suffered. These might include medical bills, lost wages, emotional trauma, and other effects of the incident.
Beyond these elements, you’ll also need to establish that the criminal act was foreseeable. This might mean showing previous similar incidents at the property, high crime rates in the surrounding area, or other warning signs that should have prompted better security measures.
Who can be held liable besides the attacker?
While the person who attacked you bears moral responsibility, they often lack the financial resources to fully compensate you for your injuries. That’s where negligent security law becomes so important—it recognizes that others may share legal responsibility for failing to prevent foreseeable crimes.
Property owners typically bear primary responsibility, as they control the premises and set security budgets. Property management companies who handle day-to-day operations may also be liable if they neglected security concerns or failed to pass along tenant complaints to owners.
Security companies hired to protect the property might share responsibility if guards were untrained, asleep on duty, or absent from their posts. Landlords can be liable for failing to maintain basic security features like doors, locks, and lighting in residential settings.
Business operators who run establishments on the property may be responsible even if they don’t own the building—especially for security within their leased space. Homeowners’ associations that neglect security in common areas like pools, clubhouses, or parking lots can also face liability.
Can I sue if the criminal is never caught?
Absolutely yes—and this is one of the most common misunderstandings about negligent security cases.
Your claim focuses on the property owner’s failure to provide adequate security, not on catching or punishing the criminal. While the criminal act triggered your injuries, your legal action targets those who created the conditions that allowed the crime to occur through inadequate security measures.
Many successful negligent security cases proceed with the perpetrator never identified or apprehended. Your case will center on proving that:
- The property owner knew (or should have known) about security risks
- They failed to implement reasonable protective measures
- This failure created the opportunity for the criminal incident
- You suffered real damages as a result
Conclusion
When you step into any property – from an apartment building to a hotel, shopping mall, or parking garage – you deserve to feel safe. You have every right to expect reasonable security measures that shield you from foreseeable harm. Sadly, many property owners fail to fulfill this basic obligation, leaving innocent people vulnerable to crimes that could have been prevented.
A negligent security attorney becomes your voice and advocate when inadequate security leads to injury. These cases aren’t straightforward – they demand specialized understanding of premises liability law, security standards, and how foreseeability works in legal settings.
Here at The Barzakay Law Firm, we’ve seen the devastating ripple effects that violent crimes create for victims and their families. Our attorneys are deeply committed to holding negligent property owners accountable while helping victims rebuild their lives. With our offices throughout Florida – including Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Orlando, and Boca Raton – we’re ready to serve clients across the entire state.
Time limits apply strictly to negligent security claims. Evidence can vanish quickly as property owners rush to make repairs or upgrade security after an incident occurs. If you or someone you love has been harmed because of inadequate security measures, we encourage you to reach out promptly for a free consultation.
Our firm operates on a contingency fee basis – a simple promise that you pay nothing unless we secure compensation for you. This arrangement allows you to focus completely on healing while we handle the complex legal aspects of your case.
Contact The Barzakay Law Firm today to discuss your situation and understand your legal options. We’re here to help you steer this difficult time and fight for the compensation you deserve.