Show Me the Money! Average Negligent Security Settlement Amounts

Understanding Negligent Security Settlement Amounts

When seeking compensation after an injury from inadequate security, negligent security settlement amounts can vary dramatically. Several key factors influence typical settlement ranges.

Average Settlement Amounts by Crime Type:

Wrongful Death: $2.8 million average jury verdict
Robbery: $1.9 million median jury verdict, $1.6 million median settlement
Sexual Assault/Rape: $1.5 million average jury verdict, $1.2 million average settlement
Assault & Battery: $1.2 million average jury verdict, $1.1 million median settlement

Settlement Amounts by Business Type:

Apartment Complexes: $1.5 million median jury award, $1.7 million median settlement
Retail Stores: $1.7 million median jury verdict, $1.2 million average settlement
Restaurants: $600,000 average jury verdict, $2.8 million average settlement
Hotels: $1 million average jury verdict, $632,000 average settlement

Recent high-profile cases show the potential for substantial compensation. One case resulted in a $28.9 million settlement for a teenager who became quadriplegic after a shooting at an apartment complex with inadequate security. Another case resulted in a $10 million settlement for a 26-year-old who became paraplegic due to similar circumstances.

Important note: These figures come from a comprehensive study of 1,086 negligent security cases and recent case results. Your specific settlement amount will depend on the unique circumstances of your case.

There’s no standard settlement amount for negligent security cases. Each situation involves different factors like injury severity, the property owner’s negligence, and incident specifics. Understanding these variables can help you evaluate your potential claim.

Negligent security settlement amounts vocabulary:

What is Negligent Security and How is it Proven?

When you’re hurt because a property owner failed to keep you safe from crime, you might have a negligent security case. This claim falls under premises liability law, meaning property owners have a legal duty to protect visitors. When you enter a store, hotel, or apartment complex, the owner is responsible for taking reasonable steps to protect you from foreseeable dangers, including crime.

Property owners aren’t expected to prevent every crime. However, if criminal activity was foreseeable—meaning they should have anticipated it—they had a duty to act. For example, a history of robberies in an apartment complex parking lot creates a foreseeable risk that the owner cannot ignore. The legal system examines whether the owner knew or should have known about the danger from prior incidents, a high-crime neighborhood, or the nature of the business itself.

To succeed, your claim must prove four elements: Duty (the owner owed you protection), Breach (they failed to provide reasonable security), Causation (their failure led to your injuries), and Damages (the harm you suffered). You can find more info about negligent security claims on our blog.

Common Examples of Security Breaches

Security failures often involve a property owner not taking reasonable protective steps. Common examples include:

Poor lighting: Dark parking lots and stairwells can conceal criminals.
Broken locks: Malfunctioning locks on doors, gates, and windows allow unauthorized access.
Faulty security gates: Gates that remain open or are easily bypassed fail to control entry.
Inadequate video surveillance: A lack of working cameras in key areas reduces deterrence and evidence. You can learn more about video surveillance systems.
Insufficient security guards: Untrained, inattentive, or non-patrolling guards offer little protection.
Failure to monitor premises: Ignoring suspicious activity or alarms is a breach of duty.
Unsecured doors and windows: Leaving access points open invites criminal activity.

Who Can Be Held Liable?

Identifying all responsible parties is crucial for full compensation. Liability can extend to:

Property owners: They have ultimate control and responsibility for security.
Landlords: Responsible for common areas and tenant security in rental properties.
Management companies: Accountable for day-to-day operations and security failures.
Security contractors: Liable if their guards were poorly trained or failed in their duties.
Business owners: Must provide reasonable security for customers in their establishments.
Event promoters: Have a duty to ensure adequate security for attendees at large gatherings.

Our team investigates thoroughly to identify everyone who played a role in the security failure.

The Four Elements of a Negligence Claim

Proving a negligent security case requires establishing four key elements, which are vital for determining your potential negligent security settlement amounts.

Duty: Property owners have a legal obligation to protect lawful visitors (customers, tenants, guests).
Breach: We must show the owner failed in this duty by providing inadequate security, such as ignoring prior crimes or falling below reasonable security standards.
Harm: This refers to your actual injuries and losses, including physical, emotional, and financial damages.
Causation: We must connect the security failure to your injuries, demonstrating that with adequate security, the incident likely wouldn’t have happened or been as severe.

Proving your case requires careful evidence gathering, including police reports, witness statements, surveillance footage, and security logs. We investigate the history of criminal activity on the property and in the area, as prior incidents establish that the owner had “notice” of the risk. This comprehensive approach builds a strong foundation for securing fair compensation.

What Factors Influence Negligent Security Settlement Amounts?

Negligent security settlement amounts are not determined by a simple formula. Every case is unique, and its value depends on multiple interconnected factors that we evaluate during case valuation and settlement negotiations with insurance companies.

Insurance companies have teams working to minimize payouts, which is why strong legal representation is crucial. You can learn more about How to Maximize Your Settlement Offer with a Personal Injury Law Attorney to understand the strategies involved. Settlement negotiations can be lengthy, and insurers often start with low offers. Understanding the factors that influence your case value puts you in a better position to pursue fair compensation.

The Severity and Type of Your Injuries

The most significant factor is the severity of your injuries. More severe injuries require more extensive treatment and result in permanent life changes, deserving greater compensation.

Catastrophic injuries like spinal cord damage leading to paraplegia or quadriplegia typically result in the highest settlements. Cases involving such life-altering injuries demonstrate how dramatically settlement values can increase.

Beyond physical harm, psychological trauma can be profound. Many victims develop Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), anxiety, depression, and other forms of emotional distress. These psychological wounds are real and compensable.

In wrongful death cases, settlements account for the loss of life, funeral expenses, and the financial and emotional impact on surviving family members. These cases often result in some of the highest awards. For more detailed information, you can read about More info on Injuries Seeking Maximum Compensation.

Calculating Economic and Non-Economic Damages

We pursue two main types of damages in negligent security cases.

Economic damages are the tangible financial losses you can document. This includes medical expenses (ER visits, surgeries, therapy, medications) and lost wages (missed paychecks and reduced future earning capacity). For severe injuries, future medical care projections are critical, as costs for lifelong care can be substantial.

Non-economic damages are more subjective but equally important. This includes pain and suffering for physical and emotional anguish, and loss of enjoyment of life if your injuries prevent you from participating in activities you once loved.

Calculating these damages requires careful assessment, often involving economists and medical professionals to project future costs accurately. You can see similar principles in our article about Details on Calculating Damages in Car Accident Cases in Hollywood.

The Property Owner’s Degree of Negligence

The property owner’s level of negligence heavily influences negligent security settlement amounts. If an owner showed a high disregard for safety or was aware of risks and did nothing, the potential settlement increases.

Prior criminal activity on the property is the strongest evidence. A history of violent crimes puts the owner on notice that security must be improved. Failing to act demonstrates a higher level of negligence. Even known crime rates in the area create an obligation for owners to anticipate security needs.

Willful ignorance, such as ignoring warnings from tenants or security assessments, suggests a conscious disregard for safety and can lead to higher settlements. In cases of gross negligence—where conduct was particularly reckless—punitive damages might be awarded to punish the defendant and deter similar behavior.

Your Role in the Incident

Your own actions can sometimes influence a claim’s outcome through a concept known as comparative fault. Under Florida law, if you are found partially responsible, your compensation can be reduced by your percentage of fault. For example, if your damages are $1 million but you are found 20% at fault, your recovery would be reduced to $800,000.

This doesn’t prevent you from pursuing a claim, but it is a factor we must consider. Your shared responsibility must be significant to the incident; simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time is not typically considered fault. Our job is to minimize any perceived fault on your part. You can learn more about this concept in our article about Understanding Comparative Fault in Florida Car Crash Cases: How it Affects Your Claim.

Average Negligent Security Settlement Amounts by Crime and Business Type

Looking at real data can help you understand negligent security settlement amounts. A comprehensive study of 1,086 reported cases provides valuable insights into jury verdicts and pre-trial settlements. While the data is from a specific period, it establishes a foundation for how different cases are valued.

This analysis reveals clear patterns in how courts and insurers approach these cases. The crime type, business involved, and injury severity all play crucial roles in determining compensation.

Understanding Average Negligent Security Settlement Amounts by Crime

The nature of the crime significantly impacts potential compensation, as some crimes cause more severe and lasting trauma.

Wrongful Death: These cases consistently yield the highest awards, with an average jury verdict of $2.8 million, reflecting the ultimate loss.
Robbery: Incidents resulted in a median jury verdict of $1.9 million and a median settlement of $1.6 million, accounting for emotional trauma and property loss.
Sexual Assault and Rape: These cases averaged $1.5 million in jury verdicts and $1.2 million in settlements, compensating for severe psychological wounds.
Assault and Battery: Making up 42% of these lawsuits, these cases saw average jury verdicts of $1.2 million and median settlements of $1.1 million, with amounts varying based on injury severity.

These are averages; your individual case could fall above or below these ranges depending on your specific circumstances.

How Business Type Affects Settlement Values

Where the incident occurred matters. Different businesses have varying security expectations.

Apartment Complexes: With a heavy responsibility for resident safety, these properties paid a median of $1.5 million in jury awards and $1.7 million in settlements.
Retail Stores: These businesses faced median jury verdicts of $1.7 million and average settlements of $1.2 million, often related to robberies.
Restaurants: While averaging only $600,000 in jury verdicts, they settled for an average of $2.8 million. Bars and nightclubs were frequent defendants in assault cases.
Hotels: These establishments paid an average of $1 million in jury verdicts and $632,000 in settlements, often in robbery-related cases.

These figures show that property owners across all sectors face substantial liability when their negligence leads to harm.

Real-World Examples of Negligent Security Settlement Amounts

Specific high-value cases show the potential of negligent security settlement amounts, especially with catastrophic injuries and clear negligence.

A $28.9 Million settlement was awarded in a shooting where a teenager was rendered quadriplegic due to inadequate security at an apartment complex. This significant award was achieved even after recent tort reform, proving substantial justice is still possible.
A $10 Million settlement involved a 26-year-old man who became a paraplegic after being shot in his apartment. The complex had “wholly inadequate” security despite a history of violent crimes.
A $6 Million settlement against a Georgia flea market was a wrongful death case where a vendor was killed in a shooting, showing the severe consequences of security failures.
A $7 Million settlement resolved a nightclub shooting lawsuit, highlighting the high stakes for commercial venues that fail to provide adequate security.
A $4.4 Million appellate award was given to a man who was kidnapped from a parking garage, raped, and infected with AIDS after the owner removed a security barrier.

These examples demonstrate that when negligence is clear and injuries are severe, settlements can reach multi-million dollar figures.

Why Hiring a Lawyer is Crucial for Your Claim

While you can technically handle a claim on your own, pursuing a negligent security case without legal representation is complex and risky. You could make mistakes that jeopardize your case.

These cases involve premises liability law, statutes of limitations, rules of evidence, and complex insurance policies. A single procedural error can be fatal to your claim. Insurance companies know that unrepresented victims often settle for far less than their claims are worth. They may pressure you to accept a low offer when you are most vulnerable.

Navigating the Legal Process

The path to fair compensation involves several critical steps:

Filing a claim: This requires identifying all liable parties (owners, management companies, security contractors) and filing in the correct jurisdiction.
Findy phase: We gather evidence through document requests and depositions, preserving crucial information like surveillance footage.
Settlement negotiations: A skilled legal team knows how to calculate your full damages and negotiate aggressively with insurers who make lowball offers.
Trial preparation: If negotiations fail, we prepare witnesses, organize evidence, and develop compelling arguments for a jury.

Throughout this process, we protect your rights and help you avoid costly mistakes that could reduce your negligent security settlement amounts.

The Value of Experience

When you work with The Barzakay Law Firm, you gain a dedicated team that understands negligent security cases.

Our case investigation is thorough. We work with investigators and security consultants to review footage, interview witnesses, and analyze crime data. This often uncovers evidence that strengthens your claim.

Our liability evaluation analyzes the responsibilities of all potential defendants to ensure we pursue compensation from all appropriate sources. Our damage calculation involves working with medical and economic professionals to project future costs and lost earning capacity.

We provide strong advocacy, handling all communications with insurance companies to protect you from their tactics. We work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay no legal fees unless we recover compensation for you. We don’t want cost to be a barrier to justice.

Victims with legal representation consistently achieve better outcomes. Having a knowledgeable team fighting for you is essential for maximizing your recovery.

Conclusion

As we’ve explored, negligent security settlement amounts don’t follow a set formula. Each case is shaped by injury severity, the type of crime, the owner’s negligence, and the business involved. While we can’t predict an exact amount, understanding these factors provides a clearer picture of what to expect.

The statistics and case examples are compelling. From multi-million dollar wrongful death awards to a $28.9 million settlement for a quadriplegic teen, these figures represent real lives changed by preventable crimes. When property owners fail in their duty to provide reasonable security, the law provides a path to justice.

Often, these tragedies could have been prevented with basic security measures like working cameras or better lighting. When owners ignore these responsibilities, they must be held accountable.

Pursuing a claim alone is challenging. Insurance companies have lawyers working to minimize payouts. Having an advocate who understands premises liability law, knows how to gather evidence, and can negotiate effectively is crucial.

Your situation is unique. What matters most is ensuring all your losses are properly valued so you receive the compensation you deserve.

If you have been the victim of a crime due to inadequate security, understanding your legal options is the first step. At The Barzakay Law Firm, we’re here to help you through this challenging time. Contact a Security Negligence Lawyer in FL to discuss the specifics of your case. Your path to justice starts with that first conversation.

Contact Us

Practice Areas